No I would say that's only a universal opinion of those that have fallen in love with McGehee's production and aren't being objective. He's made some nice plays in the past 2 weeks, but he has had his stretches where's been abysmal in the field as well. Throughout his minor league career Total Zone had him as a scratch defender, he was as average as average gets in 993 chances (Minor League Splits, no linkage is available from that site). I've watched all the same games and I see him as an average defender with below average range. Gamel has above average range, a similar glove to McGehee, but unfortunately he's not able to accurately throw across the diamond. Most of Escobar's errors are of the throwing variety as well, it is it a tough sell to believe he could be an above average defender? This reminds me quite a bit of the Braun debate from last season... even the people who made excuses for Braun in that past aren't going down that road anymore, he's clearly a bad outfielder, even to the eye test. Casey is in his peak as a player and he's average at best, he's not going to get better, and in fact he'll likely slowly decline as his range further erodes with age. Furthermore I feel you're disdain for Gamel is misplaced at best. You've take your frustration regarding the many criticisms of Macha and focused it into a McGehee vs Gamel debate, when that's not the point people have been making for over a year. I don't really want to rehash the whole Gamel PH debate, I think the evidence is pretty clear that it ruined his confidence, he wasn't the same player in AAA as he was before the promotion. It's very clear his MLB experience last season has adversely affected his short career. We get that you don't care about service time, but that doesn't make your opinion on the matter correct. I believe you're clearly biased in that you believe Casey is the superior player in every way. He may certainly end up to be the more productive player in the end but Gamel has the vastly superior tools... he's faster, has better range, a better arm, and I still believe that he has the potential to hit for more power. Your refusal to accept that Gamel was misused once again calls into question your credibility and objectivity. Casey took advantage of his opportunity, he also gets the most out of what he has, but just because he got the first shot and made the most of it doesn't mean he's clearly the superior player. Then again you'll probably argue that it made sense for Lucroy to come up and burn service time playing every 5th day behind Kottaras when the site is debating how wasteful the organization was with his service time, but I guess we'll cross that bridge when we get there.