again i never said Spurling was a bad pitcher. All I said was if you look at the pen, and Melvin wanted to get rid of a pitcher, i would choose Spurling. Currently Cordero Turnbow Wise YoGo Villy Shouse (just barely) has more value in my opinion, than Spurling. Every reliever has cost us games. The better question is how oftern does it happen. Cordero was so good for so long, the fast he blew 2 straight relieve appearances, should be treated differently. If Parra i going to come up, one of the relievers needs to go down. If not Spurling and instead of trashing my opinion, suggest a different one.