A Miniature In-Season Roster Battle: Blake Perkins, Brandon Lockridge, Luis Matos and Brewers' 4th Outfielder Job

[Harold Hutchison]

Image courtesy of © Benny Sieu-Imagn Images

 

The regular season is not the ideal time to have a roster battle. For one thing, the games count in the standings, and when you don’t have a roster spot sorted out in the regular season, it can put some games in the 'L' column that may not have needed to be there.

That said, in the wake of an injury to Jackson Chourio and a lack of collective faith in Blake Perkins, the Brewers have created an in-season roster battle for the fourth outfielder spot. As has been the case with some of their other roster battles, it’s hard to see how the team could go wrong. They have Perkins, who seems to have fallen out of favor but has a high floor; Brandon Lockridge, about whom the organization is more excited; and a newcomer, in ex-Giants outfielder Luis Matos.

The Current Situation
The Brewers found out shortly before Opening Day that Jackson Chourio had a fractured finger, suffered during a March 4 game in the World Baseball Classic. Remembering how the decision by William Contreras to tough out a similar injury had affected his offense, the team put Chourio on the injured list to recover, calling up Perkins from Triple-A Nashville to backfill the spot.

The Brewers had planned to roll with Brandon Lockridge as the fourth outfielder before Chourio’s injury. Lockridge is now, of course, splitting time with Jake Bauers in left. So, how does this competition shake out? Let’s look over the three players.

Blake Perkins
Perkins, in one sense, is the most proven commodity. He was an elite defensive center fielder in 2023 and 2024, and his defense has been his calling card. Offensively, he's been at least intermittently competent, with his primary offensive asset being his speed.

His pesky style at the plate can often draw his at-bats out, even when they end in outs. That can have an effect on the field, even if the box score doesn’t look pretty. Don’t take my word for it; just ask White Sox Opening Day starter Shane Smith what happens when a pitch count runs up.

Perkins is a valuable complementary piece for the team, and while his offensive stats are weak and worsening, he sometimes enables Brice Turang, William Contreras, Christian Yelich, and Chourio to do the real damage against a pitcher he’s helped to wear down.

Brandon Lockridge
During spring training, Lockridge looked very impressive, powering four home runs en route to a 1.059 OPS. Not bad for a player who was picked up in a late-season rush for outfield depth after Chourio went on the injured list with a hamstring injury, in exchange for Nestor Cortes and minor-league prospect Jorge Quintana (who had been bypassed by Jesus Made and Luis Pena).

Lockridge is someone manager Pat Murphy has been high on, and on teams with far less outfield depth, he’d probably be a solid starter. He’s got more speed and plays excellent defense, but it remains to be seen if he can translate his spring training breakout into regular-season results. His numbers (.348/.423/.391) so far reinforce the spring success and a big increase in bat speed hints that it's sustainable, but it's been all of 27 plate appearances.

Luis Matos
Matos was an intriguing pickup for the Brewers, partially because they already had a lot of outfield depth on the 40-man roster. In addition to Chourio, Sal Frelick, Garrett Mitchell, Perkins, and Lockridge, there’s also Akil Baddoo, Christian Yelich, Bauers and Tyler Black, and only after they brought in Matos and made Cooper Pratt's extension official did they jettison Steward Berroa. However, Matos is only 24, and his bat could be quite dynamic. He's shown the capacity to play above-average defense in the corner spots, too.

The issue with Matos, of course, is roster flexibility. The Brewers were able to pick him up for some cash because Matos was designated for assignment and is out of minor-league options. In essence, hitting coach Daniel Vogelbach and his team will have to develop Matos in Milwaukee. That said, Matos is much younger (24) than Perkins and Lockridge (both of whom are 29), so the upside could be longer-lasting if they can hold onto him and tap into his talent.

Overview
It’s hard to see how the Brewers could go wrong with any of these players when Chourio returns from the injured list. With minor-league options, Perkins and Lockridge could go down to Nashville. Matos may have an edge, simply because he can't similarly be shuttled down, but he'll have to quickly prove he can make the changes the team wants to see from him. For now, Lockridge remains the obvious leader of the pack.

 

View full article

[Snoebird]

If Perkins continues to look overmatched at the plate, it wouldn't hurt to consider Luis Lara as a call-up. He's always been an exceptional defender and a base-stealing threat, and it looks like he's added some power to his swing. Could be a spark plug for the lineup. 

[Turning2]

Too many of the same type of complimentary players in the OF.