I completely agree on that take, FTC. Unless he's just terrible in ST, imo you send a really bad message to the entire youth ranks of the organization if you send Peralta back to AAA to make room for Narveson (though it's the type of move Melvin has made time & time again). Wily struggled early in '12, but more than righted the ship with Nashville, earned a call-up, and posted brilliant results over his 5 big-league starts (2.25 ERA). He's proven that he belongs in MLB, and to hold him back so Narveson can pitch to his career 4.60+ ERA just makes no sense to me. The only angle I could sorta get behind is to keep Peralta from burning a full year's service time in '13, but even that isn't enough for me in this specific case. I'm glad Narveson looks to be well ahead of schedule & ready to go, but this just reminds me of the McGehee/Gamel situation (yes I realize Gamel didn't help himself as well), and I don't want Melvin making the same mistake. Narveson would be a nice asset in the bullpen, and is such a pro's pro that I doubt he'd take too long to get stretched out in case of an injury to one of the five best SPs in the organization.