He's been a really good player and I like him, but I think he's a notch below elite. I think you're overlooking just how valuable his bat was at catcher. Jorge's a HoFer for me. Players with a lower career OPS+ who are in the Hall: Lou Bodreau Joe Gordon Tony Lazzeri Joe Cronin Andre Dawson Casey Stengel Hughie Jennings Carlton Fisk Roberto Alomar Gary Carter Bobby Doerr Robin Yount Hary Hooper Ryne Sandberg ... and the list goes on further than that -- including seven of the HoF catchers JimH5 listed in his OP. Derek Jeter also has a lower career OPS+. I realize OPS+ isn't exactly the best stat to use, but it's not bad across different eras. Keep in mind Posada is also a guy that will probably play his entire career with one team. Granted, that's the richest team in baseball, but that's still brownie points with voters, I'm sure. If you vote him in, you have to vote in Jason Kendall and a bunch of others. Kendall's had nowhere near the career that Posada has had. Kendall while he was still in Pittsburgh is a guy who can match up with Posada. Kendall for his entire career can't hold a candle to Posada. Seriously people, look at Posada's career. If anything, playing for the Yankees has hurt him imo since he's been viewed as "good but not great" because he's played alongside guys like Jeter, A-Rod, etc. Please remember this is a catcher. Hitters like him at that position are incredibly rare. EDIT: tl;dr -- Yes, he's a Hall of Famer