Not sure what you're trying to prove. Yes, his power is probably for real, and yes his defense is solid. Does "deserves a shot" = supplanting Braun or Hart? Because that seems basically to be what you're suggesting. Maybe in a less-talented organization, you have a beef, but the Brewers are fortunate enough to not need to have fringy-corner-OF guys take precedent. I like Katin; I think he brings a lot of value, but I certainly don't think he "deserves a shot" when he has to beat out Braun & Hart to get his full-time shot at the MLB level. As of today, I think Katin's best-case scenario is as a 5th OF in 2011.