This is what I' m thinking, as well. Also, I'm assuming the team is Detroit, since they are the one with advanced talks with DS. If I'm Detroit, I look hard at Villar. Villar would be better/cheaper fit for them than Kinsler. They probably want an advanced arm, as well. So.... my official guess: Detroit gets... Phillips Villar Advanced arm (Ortiz, Burnes, or F Peralta) Lower level high upside guy ( Gatewood or Harrison) Brewers get.... Verlander Kinsler, Cash That is way too much in my opinion. I'd off them Villar and Harrison for Verlander, Kinsler & Wilson. We take on all the money. Problem with all these scenarios is that Verlander will want his last year guaranteed to waive his no-trade, at which point I'm out on him.