However, I have to believe the Brewers will feel the urge to bump him up. Didn't they feel the urge to bump him up from AA a couple of weeks ago? Yeah, it seems very likely that he'll be in Milwaukee by the end of the week. If not, I can't imagine Manning getting more than one more start... at which point, Martinez is the guy. As for the "do promote/don't promote" debate, I'm not sure. Of course 3 starts doesn't in itself earn a promotion... but it's not like he was pitching poorly at Huntsville before making his way to Indy. Luis has put together a solid season's worth of starts between the two levels. I would normally advocate patience and erring on the side of more time in the minors, but three things complicate that perspective for me in this specific case: 1> He will get to start every fifth day whether he is in Milwaukee or Indy. Unlike a position player like Billy Hall or a reliever like Shane Nance, he won't spend his time with Milwaukee as a late-inning replacement that rarely plays. As a result, he will get the same amount of work at either level... so as far as his development goes, I don't know how much difference it makes. 2> The Brewers don't really have any other viable options. Perhaps Coco or Davis, but not really. If Manning struggles and both Rusch and Ford are still on the DL, the only MLB-level option is Burba. While that would make sense, it seems like Yost et. al. aren't willing to use him as a starter, preferring to keep him in the pen to eat useless innings in blowouts. 3> Martinez is old enough that pitching in the majors isn't unheard of. Plenty of guys have gotten some starts for the first time at age 23 or earlier... and as long as the club is diligent about his workload and his conditioning, everything should be fine. I don't think there is any real significant increase in the chance of an injury between AAA and the MLB. Also, he's on the 40-man roster and would only accumulate less than two months of service time. Something to consider, at least. I'm still not sure its a good idea, but I think its pretty much guaranteed to happen. And really, its not the worst thing in the world... and it could very likely turn out for the best. Thoughts? ~Bill