I don't think it's disingenuous in the least to state we have to completely gut the rotation. In fact, it's already gutted. Going into the future, let's say Nelson is a #2, Anderson can be a #4, and one of the Jungmann, Davies, Guerra, Cravy, etc ("Fringy group") can prove to be good enough to fill the #5 spot. Then we have a group of more talented guys in the upper minors (Hader, Houser, Kodi, Lopez, Ortega) from which we could hopefully fill at least one spot. This is the "throw everything against the wall and see what sticks" approach. Quantity doesn't mean four of those guys can be consistent, quality starters. Anderson has shown nothing to believe he can start, much less be a solid #4. Guerra is too old to be a part of a future contending rotation. Jungmann and Cravy? Just no. Houser, Kodi, and Lopez are getting ripped. I have no doubt someone will step up out of that group above, but not four of them. I would be thrilled if ONE on that list (including Hader) can develop into a reliable MLB SP. And yes, trades can bring in more pitching talent. But all of this is pure speculation, and there's just no way this all comes together in the next year or two.