Are there exceptions? Of course. Does any of us know ahead of time who are the exceptions? No. All I know is it's unlikely that Betancourt will continue to beat his batting projections by anywhere near as much as he has been the last two months. It's also unlikely that Kotsay will continue to bat three-something with RISP. That doesn't make me a pessimist; that doesn't keep me from enjoying this wonderful season. It's just the reality of the situation. It's unlikley that Betancourt will stay as hot as his last two months, but it is likely he can retain his current OPS for the rest of the season. Just as he isn't as great of a hitter as he has shown recently, he's also not as bad as he performed earlier in the year. As Denny Green would say "He is who we thought he would be." As far as Kotsay goes, we just disagree. His stats for the past four years tells me one thing. He shouldn't be a starter. Guess what? He's not. His job is to PH, and he has done that well. Now to get that out of him, you do need to give him the occasional start to keep him sharp. That hurts a bit, but it's worth it to get a few game winning RBIs out of him. As much as I wanted green up earlier this year, and still do, I wouldn't want either Green or Gamel in that role over Kotsay. I don't care if his OPS was .150 over the past 4 years. He's delivering when called upon THIS year, and that's all that matters. You mention what history shows us. THAT'S what history shows us. A player is in the right situation at the right time, and it just works. Stats may say it isn't supposed to happen, it just does.