May have a case in 2011??? Escobar posted a .633 OPS and Betancourt posted a .652 OPS. Add in 26 SB's and the difference probably closes to negligible at the plate. Escobar was one of the better defensive SS's in MLB, Yuni was the worst. Escobar was a 2.2 WAR player, Yuni was .5 WAR Why bother comparing 2010 Escobar to 2011 Yuni? Obviously Escobar was a rookie in 2010 and he would only get better (as he proved in 2011). It wasn't even close, in 2011 Escobar was the better player and that's what matters. There are obviously other considerations and I am glad we traded Escobar, but in a vacuum Escobar as our 2011 SS > than Yuni so not sure how you can argue Yuni was an upgrade. It is apparent you don't think much of Escobar and that is fine, but at least fake objectivity.