I think Kotsay may be a better PH than Boggs. Maybe, but there really isn't anything that backs that up other than he is older and more experienced players might be better at pinch hitting. If Kotsay is a better pinch hitter the difference is pretty minimal. I would rather have the more versatile player on the roster. One who can play defense. The real problem, as Casey pointed out, is that Ronald has pretty consistently made less than optimal decisions with the lineup. Mostly Kotsay(doing more than pinch hitting) and Gomez decisions(#2, still?). That is troubling by itself. He obviously thinks Boggs is a better defender than Kotsy because with both playing Boggs was in CF. That leads me to believe that he thinks Kotsay is a much better hitter than Boggs or that defense matters very little.