Contradiction overload. You say he's not scoring enough runs and then post stats that say over half of his at bats this season have come before players like Cody Ransom, Cesar Izturis, Jeff Bianchi, Martin Maldonado, pitchers and pinch hitters. It's hardly a contradiction. Want to eliminate the stats from when he's batting sixth, and concentrate on his productivity when he's batting leadoff or second only? Neither actually. When you start splitting up stats they become less and less useful for predicting future production and that is what most people care about(or should at least). If you are going to continue using small samples there is nowhere for this discussion to go.