Points East Pub and it's not really even close. I fancy myself a wing expert as well, but I'm really picky about them. I think that most of them aren't that great. But I sure do love a good wing when I find it. Also good: Magoo's in West Allis, Red Rock on Water St (love the Confessor), Barnacle Bud's, and Paulie's in 'Stallis serves Legend Larry's wings, which are pretty good too. Points East are a dry wing, whereas most of the others noted are wet. They're expensive everywhere, which is very annoying to me. I personally think Garibaldi is the most overrated wing place in the city. They were small, not very crisp, and oversalted last time I had them. I live across the street from Pizza Shuttle and find their food mostly disgusting... but you guys are making me want to give their wings a chance. I do the yelp thing, and I have a list: http://www.yelp.com/list/a-wing-a-ding-ding-milwaukee