I'm not sure how the Wii works with 2K. I bought a 2K game a few years ago and returned it. Not sure if you've played them both, but in my opinion the Show is way way WAY better. I am not a huge video game guy, but I plunked down the $250 on a PS3 JUST to play MLB The Show. Over a year later, another copy of the Show purchased, and I do not regret that decision at all.