"1, Carpenter vs. Grienke Even. That's assuming Grienke is closer to the 09 version and/or that Carpenter at 36 should regress some." If Greinke is '09 Greinke, he is the best pitcher in baseball by a LOT. Carpenter couldn't touch him with a 3.0 WAR pole in 2009. 9.4 WAR! 9.4!!!! "2. Wainwright vs. Gallardo. Edge to Cards. Wainwright was the best pitcher in the NL last year through mid August but stumbled down the stretch. Yo has yet to be as consistent over a long period." Agreed. I would take Wainwright over Gallardo for a season. Gallardo being 4 years younger is nice, though. "3. Marcum vs. Garcia. Edge to Brewers. Garcia's numbers were a bit misleading. His WHIP of 1.316 wasn't nearly as good as Marcum's last 3 full seasons. Garcia is not likely to repeat a sub 3.00 ERA." They are very similar pitchers. I take Marcum only because he has proven it for more than one season. If last year's Garcia is legit, he may be better than Marcum. 4. Wolf vs. Westbrook. Even. Both veterans with similar numbers. I'd take Wolf. The worse infield defense that STL is going to play this year is going to hurt Westbrook for sure. "5. Narveson vs. Lohse. Edge to Brewers. Lohse was ghastly (worse than Suppan) in 2010 with a WHIP of nearly 1.8 and an ERA over 6 and a half. If you assume Narveson wasn't fluky, he's better than Lohse at this point." Agreed. All in all, though, the Brewers now have the pitcher with the most upside of any team in the NL Central (and yes, that includes Chapman).