"No, no, no ,no and again no. Counsell can't be the big half of a platoon. " Why not? At this point, the Brewers have 3 SSs on the roster. If Counsell plays decently, great, keep starting him. If he fails, gets hurt, or breaks down, they still have 2 relatively viable options in Wilson and the Yunibomber. Losing Counsell is not going to hurt the team much if it happens. If it allows the Brewers to win a game or so extra over the course of those starts, I'm all for it.