Fielder isn't a good fit for this team next year, hence the reason we should be looking to trade him. Couldn't disagree more - I think he is arguably the most important position player on the team. Why? Because he is the only LH bat in the lineup, and a major impact LH bat at that. Gamel has a good bat but isn't going to match what Fielder produces, but if he replaces Fielder they still only have one starting LH position player. The Brewers need LH/RH balance in the lineup - that has been a point of Melvin's in the draft the last 3 years picking LH bats such as Morris/Hawn this year, Davis/Walla in 2009, and Schafer/Komatsu in 2008. Opponents can stack RH relievers against MIL and bring in LOOGies against Fielder. They need more LH bats in the lineup. Then there is the psychological impact of having Fielder in the lineup and the mental stress of facing him, plus the merchandising value of the jersey sales, etc., because he is the face of the organization. So if I'm the GM of a team, what would I trade to get Fielder? Depends on how much I need LH bats and whether or not I have the DH or who I have at 1B. But... if Fielder was on another team, and with the Brewers in need of LH bats, the only players that I would not trade for Fielder would be Gallardo and Odorizzi. The money doesn't matter because the Brewers will have at least $30M net coming off the payroll this year. I'd trade Lawrie straight up, or something like Heckathorn+Jeffress+Schafer (i.e. three prospects rated between #5-15). As others have said, if you lose him you get two comp picks likely to be 1st round and supplemental 1st round, so he is worth at least that much. Really, a consistent .400 OBP, .500+ SLG LH hitter in his mid-20's? That's the type of player you give $15M/year to.