That was about as much of a "told ya so," post as you can get. Coming back after Knebel goes on the DL and repeating what you'd previously said? Coming back after he gave up 2 runs wouldn't have been much of a told ya so given his entire argument was you can't look at his results based on 3.1 IP...which I don't think was ever the basis for the complaints we'd basically given Knebel away. The argument from many has been that were pro trade has been 1. Knebel cost too much for a reliever with question marks especially given the Brewers payroll and what role Knebel would play in our bullpen 2. Those question marks include injury history 3. And whether he is still a really good relief pitcher After the first month of the season Knebel is hurt again and likely out through the all star break according to reports. His stuff looked good to great right off the bat. He struggled his last two appearances which could both be attributed to injury. The argument can go on all year but right now those who thought Knebel was not worth the risk have some valid points. Those who think his upside was worth holding on to probably do as well but the injury sure muddles that. But the injury question was always a part of the equation