I'll start at C and adjust. Bullpen usage, including his unwillingness to use Braddock unless there's multiple lefties in a row, as well as his mad insistence on burning Kam Loe into the ground, this drops him to a D. Batting Carlos Gomez 2nd for a consistent portion of the season..drops to an F+ The players "like" him, that raises him to a D-. I can't see how that is anything more than a marginal and almost meaningless quality. The Brewers didn't lose under Macha because they didn't like him. They lost because they had awful pitching. I know some will say that you can't overlook the human element. I understand that. But I counter that most of the time, these guys when they get in the batters box aren't thinking about Macha, or Roenicke, or how much they like the manager. They're thinking about hitting. This handling of the Wolf/Lucroy fiasco.......that brings him to a D--.