My point is, if I am going to spend that kind of money, I want to spend it on a non-turd. If I plan to spend that kind of cash, and I have a choice, I'd take the non-turd everytime. EDIT: Actually, if I'm spending that kind of money, I wouldn't waste it on the turd at all, I'd just save the money and let someone else waste their cash on the turd... Yes if player A is a turd and player B is a non turd and they are equally talented I would prefer player B. But if Player A is a turd and a top 10 player and player B is David Eckstein, I would pay Player A if I had the money,