He starts arbitration next year, so we do not control him for several more years. He's about to become expensive, which will become a real problem if his production doesn't return. In essence the real reason your baffled is because your stretching the facts. 3 years is several more years. How is that inaccurate? It's true that he's going to get more expensive, but it's not like his price is about to skyrocket. He'll probably get what, 3-4M as a first year arby player? A few would be more accurate, less hyperbolic. His arbitration cost this year isn't a big deal, but if he continues to perform as he has this year, he'll be non-tendered before he would normally reach free agency. If he performs like last year, it's a good move, and we'll keep him through his arbitration years. Hard to project what we'll get, as both are small samples. I find it hard to believe in him as a good hitter with that whiff rate.