The most damning decisions made by Melvin in recent years were the signings of 4 FA pitchers: Suppan, Wolf, Lohse and Garza. The first three were all virtually the same guy, veterans with long histories coming off of peak career years. Garza has been sometimes brilliant but frustratingly inconsistent his entire career. Oh the first 3 started off useful enough, but were all done before their contracts expired. Not coincidently, Attanasio was to some extent involved in all four signings, but that still hangs on Melvin. It takes an ace to get over the hump and twice Melvin pulled the trigger on trades to get one and both led to postseason appearances. But none were drafted/developed in his tenure though there's still some hope for Nelson and Peralta. Until they stop settling for at best mid rotation guys in their 30's as "big" signings and either start developing top of the rotation starters themselves, or play with the big boys in FA and pay the going rate for a true top of the rotation guy with something left in his tank, the best they can hope for is to once every 5 years or so accumulate enough in their system to swing a deal for a short term fix. The notion that they can get their by dealing off their assets for prospects is dubious at best.