So let me this get this straight... A jump on the ball doesn't matter until it matters? So I guess Braun is a good fielder until he isn't or Soriano is good fielder until he isn't? How is that logic even defensible? Even if you get to a ball and catch it your feet may not be set as well as they otherwise could be if you had time to circle the ball thus allowing a runner to move up on a weak throw, maybe it adversely affects the accuracy of a throw, etc... it could affect any number of variables on given play other than catching the ball or not. This is one aspect of baseball and outfield play that's pretty black and white, either you get a good jump or you don't, and it certainly has an effect beyond just catching the ball or not. By the quoted logic you could say just about anything... it doesn't matter if you miss the cutoff man until a runner takes an extra base, it doesn't matter if you throw ahead of the lead runner until the runner behind him takes an extra base, it doesn't matter how you grip a ball until you airmail a throw, it doesn't matter if you get your glove down until a ball goes under, and so on. If you're a professional, someone who's paid to play the game, you'd better be able to execute the routine or you are opening yourself up to criticism, well deserved criticism in my opinion. There is absolutely some natural aptitude involved, some guys just have a knack for it, but that certainly doesn't excuse poor fundamentals on regular basis. Yea, guys with good natural instincts in the outfield who don't run around in circles are guys who get to balls that the less instinctual ones miss by a few feet and end up rolling to the wall. It won't get called an error because it's not an error, instead it's just the case of a subpar defensive outfielder who is unable to get to balls the better ones do. Watching Cameron in his time here, he had fine speed, but what made him a special defender was the way the minute a ball was hit in his direction, he just instinctively knew the precise route/angle to take to for tracking the ball. Thus, he'd make catches without having to dive for that a guy like Hall would fail to get to because he wasn't able often enough to read a ball off the bat instantly. That split second of indecision is often the difference between a ball in the gap or a deep fly hitting the ground/wall instead of being caught. Andruw Jones before he got fat was the best i ever saw reading balls off the bat and making catches look simple that would have better made to look tough for lesser centerfielders.