They're not my only assessment tool. Clutch hitting starts with hitting safely in high pressure situations. You can look beyond that one metric all you want. In situations where his team was behind, Shaw failed to hit safely in 8 out of 10 at bats. That's terrible. Seriously man, this is an awful way to try to justify your opinion. Trying to equate some type of useful meaning to 72 PA of baseball is terrible, as someone else mentioned his tOPS+ suggests he has actually been above average even with this small sample. You are completely misrepresenting the meaning of statistics with this post. The stat you posted doesn't tell the story you are trying to make it tell in the first place and the reliability of the stat is too low to matter in the big picture. The stat itself isn't even the proper one to measure what you are trying to measure.