Even though he's in the minors, I think that it's more useful to look at Buchholz as a major league pitcher in terms of value. He'd be immediately ready to step into the Brewer's rotation, and would probably be in the majors and starting with most other teams besides the Red Sox. I do, however, agree with you that the Brewers should not trade a core starter while in the middle of a pennant race unless the return is too good to pass up (Buchholz) Finally, (and I apologize for making the same point several times now) I just don't think Hardy is near enough to pry Buchholz away from the Red Sox, and I may be a bigger Hardy fan than many of you (who watch him every day, ironically). In his last year of eligibility, BA had Buchholz as a top 5 prospect. He's dominated AAA three different times and has demonstrated that he CAN be a dominant MLB pitcher. Again, so as to not be obnoxious I'm going to stop there, but refer back a few pages if you want an extended defense of Clay's value. Of course, I'm with you on this one. Buchholz has a major league no-hitter under his belt. That is evidence enough that he CAN be dominant. He struggled a little at the end of last year, but I gotta believe that he'd be in the Red Sox rotation right now, but he's just the odd-man out right now. He'd probably be in almost any rotation in the majors right now. He's just stuck behind Beckett, Wakefield, Dice-K, Penny, Lester, and soon Smoltz. Most teams don't have starting pitching that is that deep. Buchholz could for sure step into our rotation and be useful. I have no doubt about that.