Hot take, but I'm going to say that both of the May/JoJo and Senzatela trades were successful.
JoJo was excellent, however. Very good in the regular season and had ice in his veins for the post season - 8IP, 1 ER, 11K.
Senzatela struggled in the regular season and had that "oh no, here is another Chaffin" feel to the trade. But was very, very good in the post season, especially against Tampa. He had some very key innings in games 3-4 with a lot of pitches thrown. 9IP, 2ER,
May was the weak link of the three. Very bad in the regular season, he was serviceable in Post season. Often with our defense not helping him. If nothing else, his presence lit a fire (much like his hair) in the IGTs... 😂
Maybe I have a lower opinion of the guys we sent off for these three players, but I think the trade was certainly worth it... Hard to win the WS without JoJo and Senz.
For the short-term, the Peralta trade did certainly hurt. Not sure what Freddy would've provided us if he stayed, but certainly more than Woody did. Sadly, Freddy didn't look great in the WS (nor in prior year's playoffs), but was solid against the NYY and CLE.
For that one, we just have to hope they can fix Sproat and Jett has a bounce back season. Short term loss,,, but hopefully a long term gain.