[sarcasm]No way. He has to be #3 (i.e. 1B)[/sarcasm] Burnitz isn't close. He had a nice year or two, but he was never THAT good, nor for very long (neither good nor with the Brewers). Jenkins is closer, but still wasn't that good either. He was a good player on a bad team, but really more of a league average guy that played here a long time. Sheets, Higuera, Cirillo, Thomas, Ogilvie, Weeks, Money, Plesac, BJ Surhoff, Lucroy, Juan Nieves (the only team no-hitter needs some credit), Rob Deer (ok, I'm stretching that one, but he was my favorite player as a kid). I think they are all in there. Sheets and Higuera had similar peaks, but Sheets lasted longer. Plesac gets under rated as a RP, but he was pretty dominant both here and elsewhere. BJ gets knocked because of high expectations as a 1st overall draft pick, but he had a long and good career overall. To be fair, Jenkins and BJ are probably neck-and-neck. Cirillo has the highest team batting average and was strong defensively. I'm surprised no one threw out Weeks and Lucroy. Lucroy was probably better overall than BJ, but didn't stay as long as a Brewer. Weeks was also tainted by being the #2 overall pick and we expected more from him. But he was still pretty good. From that group, I would pick: 9 Sheets 10 Cirillo