At this point I would say experience playing 1st base means very little. 1st base is one of the easiest positions to play. Gamels problem at 3rd is not him fielding the ball, it is his throwing accuracy. He has good range at 3rd. IMO he would be able to move over to 1st and be a solid 1st baseman, the only reason he hasn't is because there is still a chance he could become a solid 3rd baseman defensively. You are right that Laporta does walk more, but he also strikes out more. LaPorta has a walk ever 6.7 ABs, Gamel has a walk every 9.2 ABs. It might be a stretch to say he walks "far more frequently". I think both will be good players, I was not trying to be negative toward LaPorta.