What reason do we have to believe he is cooked? Sure, he's struggled out of the gate, but I'm sure you can find quite a few stretches of three consecutive starts in his career that were far worse than these three. There's no reason to believe that over the last winter Doug Davis' pitching ability became significantly worse. With the D-Backs, Davis' fastball had average velocities of 84.1, 84.5, and 85.1 in 2007, 2008, and 2009, respectively. Thus far this year, it's averaging 84.0, without this game. Again, Davis has made a pretty good career for himself despite being a soft-tosser. Just give him some time.