I gave him a 1 as well, because he is easily one of the worst defensive first basemen in the league. When Fielder makes a scoop I am really pumped because he fails to do so most of the time. Like a previous OP stated, in the bigs scooping low throws should be routine. I know he can't control his body type, but that still doesn't mean he deserves a better defensive grade because of it. Horrible range, horrible arm, below average glove, and short = horrible. With the bat he is unreal, but that is for a different thread.