He was/is the Brewers #1 prospect. That's why people expect him to be better than MLB average OPS, no matter how good his defense is. I don't have those expectations, just pointing out why many fans expect more. If he was the 18th ranked prospect, it wouldn't be an issue. Yup. I posted last year that Arcia was only going to disappoint fans (especially the casual ones). He's been labeled a top Brewers prospect for a couple years so people are going to assume a Weeks, Hardy, Braun, Fielder, Hart type player but he's not.