hmm, Mark McGwire has failed for a few years now and Sammy Sosa (600+ HR) might fail as well. Or were you just referencing "clean" players? (Sheffield may be "clean" because he never appeared on a "list" but that doesn't mean he didn't use. Yeah, I meant guys without the taint of steroids. I don't think Sheff gets in even if he doesn't play in the steroid era. McGwire and Sosa would both be in, easily, if they weren't tainted. Didn't Sheff admit to unknowingly using the "cream"? Maybe I'm confusing him with Bonds but I though Sheff admitted it too.