I agree with everything you wrote. It's no disrespect to Wolf to say it's far more feasible that say a Peralta or Estrada could match his numbers than Gamel could match Fielders and as good as K-Rod was in a Brewer uniform his overall numbers, 2.64 ERA, 1.298 WHIP get matched by young power arms that seemingly come out of nowhere every season. I know fans don't like to face it, but Fielder is on a HOF career track. I don't think Gamel is. That being said, even if Fielder were interested in a one year deal, Melvin doesn't seem inclined to want to bother having to move guys. You make a very good point about Fielder and Gamel. The defensive upgrade will be good but I don't think it will be near enough to make up for the offensive decline. Fielding is an elite hitter and Game is still, at best, a promising prospect whose ceiling isn't even close to Fielder. Wolf has been good but he's going to decline sometime, very possibly this year, and could much more easily be replaced than Prince. And while K-Rods don't grow on trees, they come around pretty often and randomly and are much, much cheaper.