Disagree. It depends what your goals for the game are. If the #1 goal is to make baseball as fair of a game as humanly possible, then yes. However, some might say that baseball is a form of entertainment, and it certainly makes the game more "entertaining" when the human element is involved. Baseball is an emotional game, and the "human element" makes it moreso. (I wouldn't consider myself as particularly leaning in either direction, just pointing out competing viewpoints) My thoughts exactly. Even if you have the replay option for every call the human element is still involved in instances where you have to choose where to put runners. For example, two outs and a runner on first. Ground ball hit to the second baseman who makes a diving play in shallow right field. The umpire calls the runner at first out but after replay he is safe. Now a fast runner is going to get to third on that play. How are the umpires going to determine if the runner gets third or not? If the call was safe at first they might have thrown to third and got the runner out. There are way to many variables involved and it will all be decided by the human element. I say leave replay the way it is now. Adding it in more circumstances is just going to become a mess.