I'm not saying he would be horrible as a backup. He'd be a major upgrade over Counsell. That said, I don't want Melvin selling me that he's any sort of solution at short. If he was a lefty hitter and could be platooned, I might be on board, but he's not. I will be tremendously disappointed if they make a trade with the Dodgers and get Carroll when Furcal is available. There is lots to like about Furcal- switch hitter, tons of postseason experience, generally a solid fielder, etc. Yes, he's been bad this season due to the wrist thing, but last year he hit .300 and was an All Star, it's not like he's been circling the drain for a few years or something. Let's just say if the Brewers trade for Carroll, I'll have to replace my picture.... RockCo you and are in 100% concurrence. Trading for Carroll to be a backup at SS/3B when we have the black hole triumvirate of Betancourt/Counsell/Wilson occupying 3 roster spots is definitely an upgrade. However, this does nothing to solve the real problem which is a longterm STARTING SS upgrade. I want no part of Carroll as the 2012 starting SS. I would be comfortable with Ryan, Barmes, Desmond or Furcal opening at SS in 2012. Additionally, these are the names we likely will be looking at acquiring anyways for 2012. Why not make the move now? I just noticed on Baseball Reference, Carroll has a negative dWAR this season but he's played at 2B and SS. Anyone know, what his dWAR playing SS?