Good post Eye Black/Breen. The only truly BAD thing a GM can do is make terrible long term FA signings and trade away prospects who turn into all-stars. Evaluate Stearns on his signings of Cain, Yelich and Garcia, and his trading away of Dubon, Grisham, Harrison, Diaz, Brinson and Yamomoto (Although getting Yelich is a move that quite obviously is a HUGE win for Stearns in a way that should cover many, many of his misfires) GMs can also to GOOD things by finding diamonds in the rough. Stearns has almost done this but not quite with guys like Shaw, Aguilar, Thames and the host of short term guys we've cycled through the last few years (Pomeranz, Jordan Lyles, Moose, Grandal) Signing low risk veterans on short contracts to fill out the roster (Smoak, Sogard, Holt, Gyorko, Lindblom, Phelps) is just something that had to happen but shouldn't really be judged one way or the other. They are inconsequential moves as far as the "direction of the franchise" is concerned.