That's because you are thinking like a fan, not like a GM of of a professional baseball team.That could be because I am a fan, and not actually a GM (nor to I attempt to perpetrate one). If I was a GM, I would think... "Matt, $120 million smackers sound good for 7 years? Yes? Well OK then, don't drop any more fly balls in the playoffs, cool? Great, welcome back." However, if I was GM of, say, the Milwaukee Brewers, it would be more like... "Matt, $70 million smackers sound good for 5 years? No? Well fine, go play for the Cardinals then."