How is making the playoffs deemed not working out? Because I believe there are 25 guys on a roster (more than that make an impact every year I suppose). Just because a a bunch of them did, doesn’t mean all 25 were automatically a success. I guess Travis Shaw worked out? We made the WC game. I didn’t say the team didn’t work out, I was speaking purely towards the opening day rotation. He made great additions, but let’s not ignore we could have had Lyles and Gio the entire season etc. He constructed a poor rotation to start the season, it just wasn’t good. He gave young unproven guys a chance and 2/3 were total flops. All I am saying is I hope he constructs a rotation this year that is actually good from the start and we don’t lose countless games for months trotting out 7 ERA pitchers until we give up on them and/or use assets to replace them. Outside of September the first month of the season, when the staff sucked rocks, was probably the best month of the season. I fail to see how you can argue we lost all those games when we in fact didn't lose many games early in the season. When we started to lose more game it was due to injury not how the rotation was constructed. Going further the rotation was built on the cheap because they spent money elsewhere. As it turns out that wasn't such a bad idea because we still managed to get into the playoffs despite a fairly significant number of key injuries. It also wasn't like we got lucky and had a bunch of career years to bail us out. There was probably more disappointing performances than better than expected ones. The way the team was constructed, not just the starting rotation, worked. You can't just look at the weakest link and blame all the losses on that. The team was built with an eye to how it would work as a whole not as a bunch of separate parts.