Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Thurston Fluff

Verified Member
  • Posts

    5,810
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Blogs

Events

Milwaukee Brewers News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Top Prospect Rankings

Milwaukee Brewers Videos

2022 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Milwaukee Brewers Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Milwaukee Brewers Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2024 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Thurston Fluff

  1. Big market teams don't want to share local revenue because that's money out of their pocket. So they demand something they know the players won't accept. It's up to the not big market teams to remind the big market teams their local revenue will not be as good if they don't have an opponent to play. If they want to form a league consisting of the Mets, Yankees, Phillies and Dodgers fine. I'm sure a league of 26 teams would do better than a four team league.
  2. Time to start following that new Indonesian league. At least we'll know one player in it.
  3. Sure they'll argue over it every CBA and the owners will try to slowly whittle down the players share every time. But what makes you think that isn't happening now? There's always going to be something they fight over.
  4. The players focus on the cap seems misplaced to me. The key for the them should be the overall amount of revenue the teams are willing to share. If they're satisfied with 50% of the revenue who cares if there's a cap? They get their share either way. All a cap would do is change which players get how much. It would hurt the agents and about .5% of the top tier players but help a lot more players who aren't on that top shelf. If the players succeed in not getting a cap but fail to get a specified portion of revenue then all the teams are allowed to use the Brewers/Rays/Guardians model and not pay anyone. It's not collusion to find a cheaper way to produce the same product.
  5. It'd still work out for the Cards if they're traded for a needle mover.
  6. It's easier to do when you know how to do it.
  7. I think you mean drive a parade through.
  8. Fair point. The unknown goes both ways. Which makes a deal even less likely.
  9. Things I'm optimistic about today. We'll never have to hear about the need for a needle mover at the trade deadline again. The argument that you have to go all in or you'll never win is ended. We don't have to deal with this offense isn't built for the playoffs talk ever again. The debate about whether the all in approach is better than the more bites at the apple approach is over. If we would have won it with the all in model we'd no longer have Henderson and the all in people would be saying I told you so and we wouldn't have had any way to prove we could have won it anyway. Now we don't have to argue to a brick wall that they could have won with Henderson too.
  10. I doubt they sign him before the lockout is over. Partially because it makes little sense to sign a guy before you know what the economic landscape is going to be. Mostly because signing him would force them to put him on the 40 man roster. Anyone on the 40 man can't play during a lockout. Why would they interrupt his development timeline for no reason? I have little doubt they're talking about parameters of a deal but they're not going to actually make a deal until the future of the game is settled.
  11. I think it was Melvin was the one who brought back a winning culture. Granted he followed the build a team for a short window model vs the more bites at the apple which is not my preference. But as long as a GM holds true to their philosophy they can win doing either. I think some of the avenues of team building changed over the past decade wasn't available to Melvin. Or at least it only started in 2012 with the international signing rules changes. By the time the Brewers to set up a proper scouting and development system he was at the end of his time here. Melvin didn't have a chance at the Churio's or Made's of the world because the rich teams could just buy all of them. Melvin had his faults. He ignored defense and couldn't consistently develop pitching. Pretty much the opposite of Stearns who never found enough offense. But overall Melvin was as important as anyone is brining the organization back from the abyss.
  12. Arnold no doubt walked into a good situation but he did help build said situation. I think the lesson to be learned is it's never just one person to turn things around. The Cubs and Mets should have learned that lesson now but I question if they are even now.
  13. He deserves some credit but he didn't come into an empty cupboard situation like Doug Melvin did. Melvin was a competent GM who brought the Brewers back to respectability. He never finished the job but he left the team with enough major league talent to restock the farm. A farm that wasn't exactly barren anyway. I think Mark A. deserves credit for sticking with Melvin and learning the ropes. It gave him time to understand the situation and learn what he needed to do for this team to succeed. Melvin, having successfully built two horrible franchises to respectability (even if he did fail to win it all with either) was a good person to help with that. The transition was easier for Stearns because he didn't have to tear it all down to the studs and start completely over. Plus he had an owner who took the time to learn from someone who understood how to build a decent team. All he had to do was implement his system into an already functional organization.
  14. Rereading it I didn't do a very good job of saying what I meant. Basically they'll be doing what they would in five and six but won't have the option of being additional help in game six and seven. It might only be an inning or two but those are obviously important innings. Few teams have the option of multiple relievers who can routinely shut down a team for multiple innings like the Brewers do. That makes the extra inning or two from their top two starters all the more important.
  15. I get why Tampa did this but it does make it less likely they'll be available in a game six/seven all hands on deck situation. Or at least not as effective. One reason you pitch your best early is to have them late.
  16. I'm not a fan of the NFL either. The only time I ever watch it is if I'm with someone that's watching it. MY point about the NFL was solely about the effect evening the playing field has on innovation and competence of the organization. While some teams can strip things down most poorly run teams end up back in the basement in short order or never leave it. AT the same time other teams manage to stay competitive year in and year out. Which leads me to believe innovation and competence will matter regardless of how even the playing field is.
  17. I think competency is as important when there's a cap and revenue sharing. Possibly more so. The NFL actively works for competitive balance and you still see certain teams continuously win and other lose. I'm not worried the Mets are suddenly going to be as good year in and year out because the Brewers can pay compete for players. My worry about a salary cap and revenue sharing is teams like the Brewers start to make decisions based on something other than value for the dollar. Things like paying Willy Adames because he was so important in the clubhouse type of deals are what I hope to avoid.
  18. I don't know if we will or not but one benefit of the 'more bites at the apple' approach is it makes it more likely. But lets win one first.
  19. Kaukauna high school wrestling coach Jeff Matczak is retiring. He's going out with six consecutive state titles along with... Career Record: 585–61–3. 10 Team State Championships. 24 Team State Tournament Appearances 28 FVA Conference Championships including the last 21 in a row. 24 Individual State Champions 104 State Place Winners 200 State Qualifiers—averaging nearly 6 per year I'm not sure if a coach in any sport that comes close to that.
  20. It was about how teams who don't hit many homeruns can't win in October. I could have worded it better that teams who don't hit many homeruns can't win in October. Even if they do hit a few it isn't the way they win. I disagree the Brewers needed those homers to get this far. If you count those homers as outs then yes. If you count them as doubles then they probably win anyway. There are also two other teams still playing who also don't rely on homeruns and several who did who aren't. Mainly my point is this season shows teams that hit a lot of homers aren't necessarily built better for the playoffs. Obviously hitting home runs help teams that don't rely on them. But a team who has a good offense without relying on home runs is still a good offense when they don't. A team that needs them to score isn't. Just ask the Yankees and Cubs.
  21. You're probably right but the narrative was they can't win in the playoffs not they can't win the World Series. Now we have three teams who've won series in the playoffs and one is guaranteed to make it to the World Series. When the Brewers beat the Dodgers one will be guaranteed to win the World Series as well. Two other teams that don't rely on homeruns also got this far.
  22. Of the four teams left only one ranks higher than 22nd in home runs. Two rank 27th or worse. I guess somebody forgot to tell 3/4's of the teams who made it this far you can't make it this far without being able to hit home runs.
  23. If you are then so am I. I like the short three game series because it makes teams fight for the bye. Sometimes a team can wrap up it's division early and coast the rest of the way. Having a bye to fight for makes more teams play for real longer. I'm not against the lowest seed facing the highest seed in the second round but picking the opponent seems like a gimmick. I guess it could let the top seed pick a team that had to go through their pitching staff more to get to that round but that's about it. As far as 154 games goes. Hell no. Listening to games is part of my daily life from April through September. I go through withdrawal symptoms on off days. I don't even want to talk about the horror of the All-Star break.
  24. The Brewers just beat the proverbial team that got hot at the right time. Our bullpen also out dueled the supposedly best bullpen in baseball to do it.
  25. For all the guff Ned Yost got here, he managed a small market team to two World Series and won one of them.
×
×
  • Create New...