Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Thurston Fluff

Verified Member
  • Posts

    5,766
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Blogs

Events

News

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Top Prospects Ranking

Milwaukee Brewers Videos

2022 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

Milwaukee Brewers Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2023 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

2024 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

The Milwaukee Brewers Players Project

2025 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Pick Tracker

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Thurston Fluff

  1. How is trading a fringe prospect and a 6th starter on the last year of his contract the same as trading a major league ready starting pitcher with 6 years of control left for a half year rental logically the same?
  2. If there's name recognition there's a buyer.
  3. If anything says you're the best of the best it's the next best team in the division is celebrating beating you 3 games to 2 at home to "only" fall seven games back.
  4. It doesn't have to be only 15 there are 76 full time umpires. I don't think perfection has to be the goal. Just a basic proficiency level. I'd expect a majority of umpires would qualify so there shouldn't be a shortage of capable ones. The alternative is to demote the worst ones. There are two problems with that approach. First is there is always a worst so the bottom would always be getting demoted. Second is it assumes there are superior ones in the minors.
  5. Now for something completely different. If we can rate umps ability to call balls and strikes accurately why don't we just have the umps who do it best call all the games?
  6. The Cubs are a good team not great team. The first half of the season shows they can get hot and do some damage in the playoffs. We've seen that happen often enough to think it isn't possible this season. The Brewers are a great team so lets kick them when they're down and try to make sure they don't even get there.
  7. I don't think it matters one bit. We have to beat a good team regardless of who it is. They'll also be the hottest of the teams by definition. If we play to our capabilities none of it will matter. We aren't the best team because we got lucky, or remained healthy. We are simply the best team top to bottom. If we play that way we move on regardless of who we face.
  8. He'll get some votes, and he should, but I doubt he gets it. I think Peralta's season is underappreciated by a lot of people. He deserves to be in the conversation. Truth be told I'm pulling for Skenes. It'd be nice to see Pirate fans have something to be proud of and a pitcher with a losing record winning it would finish any merit wins have left.
  9. As of now the NL central is the only division in baseball to have four teams above .500. In the NL it's the only team to have more than two teams above .500. It's hard to believe the conventional wisdom early in the season was only one NL central team was going to get to the playoffs due to how stacked the East and West were.
  10. You're making the same error as the rest of the K's don't matter crowd does. It's not about the times the out is made. It's about increasing the amount of times a should be out doesn't end up an out. Striking out leaves a smaller chance of getting on first safely than putting the ball in play that should be an out. A lazy fly to center should be the same result as a strikeout. But when we combine the number of errors, balls that gets lost in the sun, misplayed so badly they fielder never touches the ball or drops between two defenders due to miscommunication are higher than the number of strikeouts that end with the batter safe at first. That admittedly small increase in reaching first safely is not zero. Every single ball put in play has that added small chance of reaching first safely that a K does not. The correct way if stating it should be strikeouts are almost, but not quite, the same as other outs.
  11. Good question. It could also just be guys putting the ball in play more creates more chances for an error. One of the things that always bugged me about the strikeouts are just outs argument is they eliminate any chance of a error, bad hop, lost in the sunlight, misplay or a seagull getting in the way. It may be a small difference but that doesn't mean the results are the same.
  12. I have a theory about that. Teams that can buy ready made talent don't spend as much time and effort refining the support staff necessary to make average players great. Why spend a bunch of time and effort learning the exact best way for each pitcher to pitch each pitch when you can just buy the best pitchers? They never have to figure out how to make a player with average stuff better than average or how to make a player with one great trait effective because they can buy players who have all the tools or can figure it out on their own. When they can't, they just eat the money and find one that can. In a nutshell, teams forced to make do with what they have learn to make do with what they have. The ones who can just throw money at it just throw money at it.
  13. Was hoping it was an "injury" or at least something not arm related.
  14. Two Weeks, or not two Weeks, that is the question.
  15. Nothing on the team is 2 week. My joke on the other hand...pretty week.
  16. Got to think he falls asleep at night by counting the money jumping out of his future back account. I feel bad for the guy but it is kind of funny to see the Yankees give up what they did to get what he's giving.
  17. It's crazy how different Collins and Mizz got into the ROY discussion. Mizz took the league by storm but lacks the overall body of work. Collins is putting up some of the best rookie numbers in the league without anyone noticing.
  18. Perfect world scenario alert! Collins wins ROY and Mizz falls short of the threshold to get a full year of service time.
  19. How can you not consider the team with the best record in baseball a great team?
  20. It's hard to compare. Stearns had more money to spend when he got some of those free agents. Not necessarily always higher payrolls but fewer players making high salaries early in his tenure. You can splurge on Cain and Chacin when you're paying Hader, Burnes and Woody pre/early arbitration salaries.
  21. Why does this team have so much better a chance at a World Series than last season? Or any of the last seven times they've been good enough to get in the playoffs? Nor buying into the magical year mentality is the Brewers superpower. Overall I'm a bit confused with some of the complaints. I get being disappointed by nor upgrading shortstop. Yet, when adding defense into the mix, I don't know how much of an improvement could have been made. We are a top ten offense with a defense only shortstop. Was there any combination of infielder help available to make us a top five without hurting our top five defense? What I don't get is one of the complaints I've seen is we didn't improve on the margins. Yet we got a marginal improvement at catcher and reliever. Just because we didn't improve in an area fans wanted doesn't mean we didn't improve. I think it boils down to some people equating not addressing every need to doing nothing.
  22. I'd take him over Yuni B. any day of the week. Twice on double headers. You can win with one major weak spot on offense when that spot produces and defense.
  23. I think if the Brewers did a deadline trade for a veteran rental with identical numbers as Priester and Vaughn for more than they traded for Priester and Vaughn the same people complaining now would be cheering that they finally went all in.
  24. We're currently 8th in baseball in runs scored, 5th in team ERA, have one of the best defenses in all of baseball and have one of the best records against teams who would be in the playoffs today. Which is why we have the best record in baseball. We don't need to be aggressive. Other teams need to gamble their future just to be as good as we already are.
  25. Bauers is on borrowed time. Barring injury, when Hoskins comes back he's probably gone. So in reality the question should be; Is a month of O'Hearn on the bench better than a month of Bauers on the bench? Or, more accurately, how much prospect capital is a month of upgrade to a first base bench player worth?
×
×
  • Create New...