Gallardo really is a good solid #3 pitcher on a contending team, maybe a #2. Alot of fans just think of him as "the ace of the team" and when he doesn't live up to that, they get frustrated. He's a 113 ERA+ guy, 3.65 ERA, 1.240 WHIP....he pretty consistently gets those numbers and on a team with a couple of real aces he'd be one of the best #3 starters in baseball (Vogelsong, Cliff Lee etc).... some of us (myself included) thought he'd turn the corner this year and be a Cy Young candidate. He is what he is.... He's (literally) the least of our pitching worries. He's durable, he's tough, he can hit a little, he has a 2.08 ERA postseason ERA in 26 innings, he's under an extremely team friendly ($6 million a year for his production is freakin' great in this day and age) contract through 2015. After Braun, Gallardo is the last Brewer I'd trade http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/g/gallayo01.shtml