What are people basing this on? He's been really really good the last 4 years except 1 (.265 BABIP, power was down though, not sure about why). He's 26. He plays a semi-premium position extremely well. He plays every day. He didn't make sense for Milwaukee, but damn, if I were a Padres fan I'd be thrilled. I base this on the fact that a player who already had character concerns just guaranteed himself $300 million no matter how poorly he plays.