Guerra's surprise 4th option certainly gives Gallardo a better chance. I have some concerns about how many retreads this team might end up having though. If you go down the roster battles one-by-one, you could make a case for guys like Gallardo, Miley, Jeffress, Guerra, and Drake, but you run the risk of failing to see the forest for the trees. They have a lot of young arms who have a good chance to be part of the team for a long time, including when they likely peak in 2-3 years. I would prefer they just throw more guys like Williams, Houser, Suter, and Woodruff into the fire so they go through some of those growing pains now. It's not like the retreads aren't almost just as likely to struggle anyway. I think they're still a very strong wild card contender either way, and they're way behind the Cubs, Dodgers, and Nationals, so why not err on the side of building for the future? 100% agree with this. Filling out the rotation and pen with retreads and reclamation projects is the "old Brewers" way of doing business, in the years where they really had no other alternatives. I understand the argument that it increases your organizational depth to hide those younger guys with options at AAA, but at some point you just end up stunting their development. Suter and Woodruff have nothing left to prove at AAA, and fit the team's "young controllable talent" mantra. I don't mind that the team gave Miley a chance to reestablish himself as a MLB pitcher this Spring Training, but I don't want him anywhere close to the team's starting rotation. This team has "been there, done that" in the past, and it almost always ends poorly. Agreed since Cobb is more likely not coming here, Woodruff needs to be in the rotation. Anderson Davies Chacin Woodruff Suter This rotation gives us the best chance at staying above water until Jimmy comes back to anchor the rotation. And if Drake makes this bullpen over Taylor I will be severely disappointed in Stearns and CC. Knebel Hader Albers Barnes Logan Jeffress Williams Gallardo