You don't? Maldonado can't hit, is 28 years old so there is likely no hope of him becoming a good hitter, and we need to start finding ways to get Lucroy off full time catching duties if we want him to be a good/great offensive player for us as long as possible. Rosario is 25 years old, fits the other half of our 1st base platoon well, allows 1 more LHP masher in there on the days Lucroy might play 1st, and isn't that terrible of a cost. Not to mention he's only in 1st year arby. I'd eat the defensive liabilities in exchange for more offense & the positional flexibility to get Lucroy off catching duties a few more games at a reasonable cost. Would you rather have Swisher? Some minor leaguer in our system who is marginable? (Clark, Rogers, etc). I'm sure Lucroy could help Rosario out on his defensive deficiencies.