The problem with this logic is you get to take last years disappointments/underperformances and then compare that to all the 2020 players like we won't have guys be big disappointments. Reality is we will have big disappointments in 2020 once again. Hopefully not to that extent, but there will be. Using that kind of logic always paints the future a lot more pretty than it is. I do think they trimmed off some worthless ABs and will have more average ABs...does that outweigh the above average ABs they are losing? Unknown. Some of them will be disappointments, some players will also perform better than expected. But it also goes both ways; Grandal, Thames and Moose could have terrible 2020s too. Whether you look at just 2019, 3-year averages or projections, I still have a hard time seeing this team not be better than 2019. I don't believe this team will lose any above-average ABs at all, and will in fact gain a lot of them. Offense doesn't worry me at all. But defense is worse, and I still like to see pitching adressed. Sure, I am not necessarily disagreeing with your overall point...I just feel that is an easy way to analyze any upcoming team to make it sound like it will be better. It would be pretty hard for us to have players flop as badly as Shaw/Aguilar did. Hiura having a sophomore slump and/or Braun just simply having a disaster year (at his age) are very real possibilities. Yelich could have a "down" year and lose us a lot of 2019 offense. Overall I don't think the offense is woefully different. If Cain rebounds a bit and Urias can make SS at least someone relevant on offense that would make a huge difference. I do differ with you on above average ABs though. I think we are losing some of the more elite production Grandal/Moustakas gave us, but are somewhat canceling that out if we are getting rid of the pitcher quality ABs/ Not only was Arcia a total trainwreck, but so was the bench a lot of times and the injury replacements. I think the depth is a little more average and that is always a big deal when injuries do happen. Of course Urias, Cain, Braun, and Hirua are all red flags for notable disappoint in my eyes. The later because he had elite production last year and he could be a prime candidate for a sophomore slump.