Their defense could have been better over the years, but all of this is still true: Rodgers won his first NFCCG with a QB rating in the 50s. The following year had 10 points in the 4th quarter as a 15-1 #1 seed at home. He was MVP. In 2014 he threw 2 picks and again, they basically couldn't score, then choked the game away at the end. Last year, he had multiple 4th quarter chances to play his way into the Super Bowl and they lost. There are always multiple ways a team could be better or other things that could have happened to help the Packers win, but at this point it's hard to look past the brutal truth that Rodgers also had chances to win more titles. I think he's had a pretty rough run of poor luck, and the margin between champion and contender is sometimes razor thin, but he has played a role in the shortcoming of the last decade. This is a great post, but you are forgetting a few examples as well. 2016 NFC Championship: 0 points at halftime 2019 NFC Championship: 0 points at halftime There are many variables to a football game, but it's tough to go to Super Bowls when your QB is generally terrible in conference championship games. Luckily the defense and a great punter overcame it vs Chicago 10 years ago otherwise we'd have quite the title drought. If you want to know why the Packers in the '60's won so many titles, look at Starr's numbers in the postseason. They're incredible even by today's standards.