1-2 are going to have to play at some point. better to have them meet in the quarters than not at all. Besides, Oshkosh West had lost 1 game all year at that point, so it wasnt like Vincent or Memorial would be going up against some sort of inferior competition. Besides, just because all these Milwaukee Schools are ranked highly doesnt mean anything. There are a lot of really good schools in the FVA and in other conferences as well. It would seem ideal to have 1-2 meet in the state finals, not the quarters. After beating the 2nd ranked team in the state last season, Vincent went on to play a Kimberly team that was 13-13 and beat them by 25. Can you honestly say you want to see that in the state semi-finals? I am not saying Oshkosh West is a bad team or the FVA is a bad conference, but history shows the City Conference is the toughest and the best. Since 1990 (18 years) a city team has been in the finals 16 times, and won 11 championships. Two times it was an all-city championship. 4 of the best city teams, Washington, King, Tech, and Bay View, are in the same regional, along with Tosa East and Pius, and obviously only one them can make it to the tournament. Its obvious the WIAA is more concerned about having teams from all over the state make it, rather than the best ones.