I'd probably change the NLDS roster as minimally as possible. Just focus on the needs against the Dodgers that aren't currently being fulfilled. Situational lefty: Add Cedeno Initial Out Getter with great numbers against the Dodgers: Add Davies Counsell said pre-NLDS that he really wished he could've had Cedeno on the roster. He also said Peralta was on there because of previous success against the Rockies and even then he didn't pitch in the series (I know he was being held back if possible for game 4, but still). For a 7-game series, I don't think they'll want to go with less than 12 pitchers, particularly if some of the IOG's don't go very deep, so in order to add Davies they'll need to remove a position player. Infield seems pretty thin without Schoop, so you're probably looking at one of Santana/Broxton/Granderson. They all have a niche: Santana: Best righty power bat off the bench. Won't play defense unless absolutely necessary. Broxton: Great defensive replacement, fastest player on team, good power bat, hit a homer in NLDS. Granderson: Decent defense in outfield, only lefty non-starter off bench. Given the Dodgers' lefty-heavy rotation (Kershaw/Hill/Ryu), I'm not sure how valuable Granderson is off the bench, as most games we will probably have either Shaw our Moustakas out of the starting lineup. I'm not saying Granderson wouldn't have value but for this particular series, I think he might just be the 26th guy I'd want on the 25-man roster. So to sum it up: + Davies, Cedeno - Peralta, Granderson