There is absolutely nothing to lose if they make this move. At least there is some possible upside with Donaldson and if it doesn't work out so what its not like we are getting anything from the position anyway.
We had Urias in AAA and decided to give him away because of his 5 million salary so all we have left is Black. Basically ignoring third base thinking we had enough with Monasterio and Anderson was foolish.
The truth is we just have very few good hitters and some really bad ones. The pitching and defense will have to continue to carry us and have to hope we can score just enough to win.
The commissioner looks like a complete fool for allowing this to happen. Teams on the cusp of contention should not be allowed to improve by picking these players up for free and I would feel the same way if the Brewers were able to improve this way.